Is Catch and Release Still Good for the Fish and Fishing?

catch and release brown trout

When I return from a fishing trip and regale my non-fishing friends with stories from the stream, I am often met with bewildered looks and a predictable slate of questions. Namely, “Where’s the fish?!” 

As a fly fisherman, it’s a question I’ve had to answer numerous times and my justification never seems quite adequate enough for a non-angler audience. During a recent round of questioning from a good friend of mine, I decided that it was time for me to take a closer look at why I actually participate in catch and release fishing and whether there are truly merits to the method.

Catch and release fishing is a common practice, especially among the fly fishing community in North America. You could go so far as calling it an ethos. When I started fly fishing, it was just presented to me as what we do. But I’d like to take a closer look at the issues and evaluate whether the evidence is there to support catch and release fishing in our modern times.

What Is Catch and Release Fishing?

Catch and release fishing is a practice wherein anglers immediately release fish – unharmed – back to the water where they were caught. If done properly, the catch and release method of fishing is purported to result in high survival rates for the fish.

‘Properly’ is a keyword here because it assumes anglers are using the proper equipment and methods for catch and release fishing. 

  • A sufficiently strong rod, reel, and line for landing the fish quickly.
  • Single, barbless hooks to reduce injury and handling time. 
  • Artificial lures or flies to reduce deep hooking.  

It also assumes proper handling. 

  • Not playing the fish to the point of exhaustion. 
  • Using a landing net made of rubber or small, soft mesh. 
  • Avoiding removal of the fish from water. 
  • Using wet hands or gloves to handle the fish. 
  • And generally handling the fish gently without squeezing or damaging the gills.

By following the proper procedures of catch and release, anglers can greatly reduce the chance of a fish’s chance of death or harm.

According to the National Park Service in the United States, the practice of catch and release benefits both the fish populations and anglers. It allows more fish to remain and multiply in a particular body of water thus giving more anglers the opportunity to enjoy the sport.

Catch and release fishing emphasizes the recreational rather than the consumptive value of fish.

The History of Catch and Release Fishing in the US

It’s unclear where and when catch and release fishing actually caught on in the US, but many believe it was in the early part of the 20th century.

Some sources claim that Pennsylvania’s Spring Creek was the first catch and release stream in the United States but others believe it was Michigan’s regulations in 1952, which limited anglers on certain trout streams with a no-kill restriction and artificial flies and lures only.

It’s evident that the practice was on the minds of early-20th century American anglers like Lee Wulff, who famously wrote in 1939: “Game fish are too valuable to be caught only once.”

There is significant evidence that catch and release fishing does, in fact, increase fish populations. In 1954, the US Fish and Wildlife Service studied the Bradley Fork and West Prong streams of the Little Pigeon River in North Carolina’s Great Smoky Mountains National Park.

What the study revealed, following a 7-year no-kill restriction in these streams, was that the native trout stocks had tripled and that on average anglers were catching fish at a rate of slightly more than four per hour.

The study was influential and in the span of just a few years federal and state agencies began implementing similar restrictions on streams in other states.

The practice has now gone mainstream in the US where, according to a 2020 report, 66% of the country’s 50 million recreational anglers release some or all of their catch. If these anglers were to kill their allowable legal limit, it would lead to the deaths of hundreds of millions of fish nationwide.

Not Everyone Is On Board With the Practice

Organizations like PETA believe that catch and release fishing is “cruelty disguised as sport” and that fish suffer significant injuries during the process of catch and release and “often die of shock.” 

Groups such as the Salmon Watchers Assistance Group in Canada have called for a nationwide ban on the practice of catch and release, stating that fish caught and returned to the water suffer significant psychological stress during the process and often die as a result.

For these groups and many people, the practice of catch and release is seen as an act of cruelty rather than one of conservation.

Is There Any Merit to the Concerns?

It is true that some fish do succumb to stress or injury when they are caught and released back into the water. But, there is ample research that demonstrates that most survive.

The factors leading to mortality include water temperature, time played, time out of the water, handling, whether natural or artificial bait was used, water depth at hooking, at anatomical hooking location. These factors can vary between species and seem to be much more critical for some than others.

But, in a number of recently conducted studies across a variety of species, the mortality rate for released fish has been calculated between 10-20%. In a report from the National Marine Fisheries Service, 53 studies determined that the average mortality rate of fish released by anglers was 18%. 

What’s the verdict?

It’s certainly true that the catching and releasing of a fish disrupts its life and, in some cases, leads to mortality. But to paint anglers that practice catch and release as cruel torturers of fish is a significant mischaracterization of the sportsmen. 

Fisheries, research scientists, and wildlife organizations are all in agreement that catch and release fishing supports the protection of fish populations and encourages population growth.

A catch and release angler that cares about the environment and the ecosystem in which he/she fishes should feel encouraged that they are fishing in a sustainable fashion as well as providing an opportunity for their fellow anglers to land the same fish in the future.

It’s this author’s opinion that the practice of catch and release fishing has numerous benefits and a limited number of drawbacks. I am sensitive to the opinions of those on the other side but believe that with the proper gear, handling, and compassion for the fish we chase, we are doing a service to mother nature and maintaining populations of fish that will be caught for generations to come.

What is your take on catch and release? We’d love to hear what you think in the comment box.

More Good Reads:

angler holding trophy northern pike catch

Fishing for Northern Pike, the Wolf of the Water

This Christmas Eve post spotlights one of the most sought-after freshwater gamefish on the planet, the Northern Pike. In life ...
Read More
bass boat speeding in lake

First-Timer’s Guide to Buying the Perfect Fishing Boat

Buying Your First Fishing Boat - What You Need to Know Spend enough time fishing and, at some point, many ...
Read More
fishing for asian carp

These 4 Invasive Fish Species Can Make You Money

Get Paid to Catch Invasive Fish - Really? It is probably the last thing you think about when fishing. Whoever ...
Read More
economic data of sportfishing in usa

Recreational Fishing Is Big Business in the U.S.

The Economics of Recreational Fishing in America Americans love the great outdoors, and this enthusiasm for hunting and fishing as ...
Read More
fly reel and rod for saltwater fishing

Saltwater Fly Reel Buying Guide: Must-Have Features and 5 Top Values

Watching line tear through the water with blazing speed can help prove whether or not a fly reel is worth ...
Read More
truck pulling boat for family fishing trip

Good Planning Is Key to a Fun and Stress-Free Fishing Trip

Going to the lake just outside of town is easy. Get off of work, get home, throw your stuff in ...
Read More
This entry was posted in Fishing Tips & Other Wonderings on by .

About Dorado

John Pardal, aka Dorado, is the editor as well as an author for Reel Adventure Fishing. He has fished extensively up and down the U.S. Atlantic coast, throughout much of Florida and a bit of the Caribbean. John loves writing about all aspects of sportfishing and is passionate about conservation and promoting sustainable fishing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *